New: ASCloud, our paperless food safety system. Full document FSMS from R3,800 a month, R638 plans from R499. See pricing

Closing BRCGS non-conformities within 28 days

After a BRCGS Food Safety Issue 9 audit, the site has 28 calendar days to send its certification body objective evidence that every non-conformity has been corrected. With that evidence go a root cause analysis and a preventive action plan with timescales. If the evidence does not arrive within 28 days, certification is not granted and the site needs a further full audit.

Those 28 days are calendar days, not working days. A site audited in the first week of December will be gathering evidence through the year-end shutdown, when contractors are away and the people who need to sign things off are on leave. If your audit has already happened and the clock is running, ASC can help you find the root causes and build the evidence pack. If it has not, plan for those 28 days before the auditor arrives, because a mock audit to the standard’s own protocol shows you the findings while there is still time to fix them.

In short

  • Evidence of correction, the root cause and a preventive action plan are due within 28 calendar days of the audit (Part III, section 2.3.2).
  • No evidence in 28 days means no certificate and a further full audit.
  • A critical non-conformity, or a major against the statement of intent of a fundamental clause, stops certification outright.
  • The grade depends on how many minor and major non-conformities are raised. Grades C and D mean a six month audit cycle.
  • At the next audit the auditor checks that the root cause was dealt with. If it was not, a non-conformity is raised against clause 1.1.12.

How the three levels of non-conformity differ

Part III of Issue 9, the audit protocol, sets three levels. A critical non-conformity is a critical failure to comply with a food safety or legal issue. A major is a substantial failure to meet the statement of intent or any clause of the Standard, or a finding that raises significant doubt about the conformity of the product being supplied. A minor is a clause that has not been fully met while the conformity of the product is not in doubt.

The difference matters for what follows. A minor and a major both go into the 28-day evidence pack. A critical means no certificate from that audit. Many South African sites still say BRC and non-conformance. The Standard says BRCGS and non-conformity, and the rules are the same whichever word your team uses.

What goes into the 28-day evidence pack

Section 2.3.2 of Part III asks for three things against each non-conformity. The first is objective evidence that the problem has been corrected, such as updated procedures, records, photographs or invoices for work done. The second is the root cause. The third is a preventive action plan to correct that root cause, with a timescale. The certification body can also decide to verify by remote assessment or a further visit.

A summary of the root cause and the proposed preventive action goes into the audit report itself. The certificate is then issued within 42 calendar days of the audit. The same rules apply after an unannounced audit.

A common weakness in these packs is a correction presented as if it were the whole answer. Fixing the gap under a door is a correction. Finding out why nobody noticed the gap, and changing that, is the corrective action the Standard is asking about.

A worked example from the factory floor

Take a minor raised against clause 4.4.8. The auditor finds daylight under an external door to the dry goods store, with no seal fitted. The pack for that finding has four parts.

  1. Correction. A brush seal is fitted to the door the following week. The evidence is a dated photograph and the maintenance contractor’s invoice.
  2. Root cause. Asking why the gap was missed shows that the monthly fabric inspection checklist covers walls, ceilings and floors but not doors, so nobody was looking.
  3. Preventive action. Doors and door seals are added to the fabric inspection checklist, with a named owner and a monthly frequency. The evidence is the revised, approved checklist and the first completed inspection.
  4. Check of effectiveness. After three months the owner reviews the completed inspections for any door defects found and fixed. Every inspection since the audit is kept, because the auditor will look for them under clause 1.1.12.

The same pattern works for a major. The evidence has to be stronger and the root cause usually runs deeper, often into training, resourcing or a procedure that does not reflect how the work is really done. Our Root Cause Analysis 1-Day Course trains the people who will write these packs to separate symptoms from immediate and root causes.

Environmental monitoring findings follow the same route, and our article on closing environmental monitoring non-conformities covers them.

How BRCGS grades the audit

Table 2 in Part III sets the grade from the number and type of non-conformities. For an announced audit the grades are as follows.

GradeNon-conformities allowedNext audit due
AANo majors and up to 5 minors12 months
ANo majors and 6 to 10 minors12 months
BNo majors and 11 to 16 minors, or 1 major and up to 10 minors12 months
CNo majors and 17 to 24 minors, 1 major and 11 to 16 minors, or 2 majors and up to 10 minors6 months
DNo majors and 25 to 30 minors, 1 major and 17 to 24 minors, or 2 majors and 11 to 16 minors6 months
Grades for an announced audit, from Table 2 of BRCGS Food Safety Issue 9, Part III.

A grade C with 2 majors, and every grade D, also needs a revisit, on site or remote, within the 28 days instead of evidence on paper alone.

Unannounced audits use the same thresholds and add a plus sign to the grade, and every certificated site has at least one unannounced audit in each three year cycle.

What stops a certificate altogether

Certification is not granted if the audit raises a critical non-conformity, or a major against the statement of intent of a fundamental clause. It is also refused when the count goes beyond Table 2. That means 31 or more minors, 1 major with 25 or more minors, 2 majors with 17 or more minors, or 3 or more majors.

At an already certificated site, the certificate is withdrawn immediately in those cases, and a re-audit cannot take place sooner than 28 calendar days after the audit.

Issue 9 has 12 fundamental requirements. They are senior management commitment (1.1), the food safety plan (2), internal audits (3.4), management of suppliers of raw materials and packaging (3.5.1), corrective and preventive actions (3.7), traceability (3.9), layout, product flow and segregation (4.3), housekeeping and hygiene (4.11), management of allergens (5.3), control of operations (6.1), labelling and pack control (6.2) and training (7.1).

Two of these have a direct link to the 28-day pack. Clause 3.7 requires the site to use root cause analysis to prevent recurrence. Clause 1.1.12 requires the root causes of the previous audit’s non-conformities to have been addressed effectively. A site that sends neat evidence for the correction but never fixes the cause can lose a grade at the next audit for exactly that reason.

The clauses that draw the most findings

For World Food Safety Day 2026, BRCGS published the five non-conformities raised most often worldwide in Food Safety Issue 9 audits from April 2025 to March 2026. They are housekeeping and hygiene (4.11.1), equipment design (4.6.2), chemical storage and handling (4.9.1.1), walls (4.4.1) and doors (4.4.8). BRCGS did not rank them or give percentages.

All five sit in section 4 of the Standard, the site standards, which is good news for a site preparing for an audit. These findings can be spotted on a walk round weeks before the certification body arrives, and a gap audit or an internal food safety audit will find them first. Our 90 day countdown checklist sets out the order to work in.

For the documents that sit behind clauses 3.7 and 1.1.12, our BRCGS Food Safety Issue 9 toolkit gives you an editable corrective and preventive action procedure and record templates, which you complete for your own site.

The 2026 position statements and where Issue 10 stands

Issue 9, published on 1 August 2022, is still the current issue. BRCGS updated its position statements to align with the GFSI 2024 benchmarking requirements, effective for all audits from 10 August 2026. The one new requirement is in clause 7.4.2, which now lists suitable protective footwear among the protective clothing a site must provide. The statements on unannounced audits, changing certification body and the definition of an initial audit were reworded.

BRCGS says Issue 10 is in development, with a technical working group whose first meeting was set for 1 April 2026 and which is expected to run for 12 to 15 months. It expects the usual six month transition once the new issue is published. BRCGS’s annual report for 2025 to 2026 says Issue 10 is planned for 2027, but no month or audit date has been announced, so sites should plan for 2027 audits under Issue 9 and keep an eye on BRCGS for the draft. Our BRCGS training courses are kept to the current issue.

Why food businesses choose ASC

Rated 4.9 out of 5 from more than 400 Google reviews across our three offices.

Gqeberha Google reviews Johannesburg Google reviews Cape Town Google reviews

Our online courses are rated 4.9 on average across 2,586 course reviews, from more than 7,100 enrolments.

ASC is ISO 9001 certified, a SAATCA registered online training course provider (TC 065), a FoodBev SETA accredited provider (No. 587/00337/1900) and an Exemplar Global Recognised Training Provider.

BRCGS audit support

Close this audit's findings and be ready for the next one

If your audit has just happened, ASC works each non-conformity back to its root cause and helps you put the correction evidence and preventive action plan together in the form your certification body asked for, with the 28-day deadline in view. If the audit is still ahead, ASC runs a clause-by-clause gap assessment, a three day internal audit on site and a mock audit to the standard’s own protocol, with findings presented on the last day and the written report within two weeks. The consultant is a registered lead auditor with Exemplar Global and IRCA. ASC is a consultancy, not a certification body.

Consulting is charged hourly, with a free, no obligation quote. Evidence that misses the 28 days means no certificate and a further full audit.

Get a BRCGS support quote WhatsApp us your audit date

Writing your own system? BRCGS Food Safety Issue 9 Document Templates Toolkit (TK05) (R6,550).

Training the team that writes the packs? Root Cause Analysis Courses Bundle, Overview and One-Day Course (R1,519 online for both courses, R1,899 bought separately).

Questions we are often asked

How long do you have to close BRCGS non-conformities?

28 calendar days from the audit, for an announced or an unannounced audit. Within that time the certification body needs objective evidence of correction, the root cause and a preventive action plan with timescales for every non-conformity.

What happens if the evidence is late?

Certification is not granted and the site needs a further full audit. At a site that already holds a certificate, the certification body may also withdraw it (Part III, section 6.4), so send the evidence well before day 28.

Does a major non-conformity mean no certificate?

Not on its own. One or two majors are allowed within the Table 2 limits and lead to grade B, C or D. A major against the statement of intent of a fundamental clause, a critical, or three or more majors does mean no certificate.

Is BRCGS Issue 10 out yet?

No. As at November 2026 Issue 9 is current. BRCGS says Issue 10 is in development and expects a six month transition after publication, but has not announced a date.

Sources

  1. BRCGS, Global Standard Food Safety Issue 9, published 1 August 2022, Part III audit protocol, sections 2.3, 2.4, 2.6, 4 and 6.4 (read in the copy BRCGS issued with its January 2026 public consultation on Issue 9, which informs Issue 10)
  2. BRCGS, F926 Position statements for Issue 9, version 4.1 of 6 October 2026 (content of version 4, 27 April 2026, effective 10 August 2026)
  3. BRCGS, World Food Safety Day 2026: from burden to solutions, safe food everywhere, June 2026
  4. BRCGS, 30 years of safer food, 2026
  5. BRCGS, Food Safety Technical Working Group: call for members, 2026

Leave a Comment

I accept the Terms and Conditions and the Privacy Policy

Exemplar Global Recognised Training Provider (RTP) badge issued to ASC Food Safety
International recognitionExemplar Global Recognised Training Provider (RTP)Exemplar Global, the international organisation that certifies auditors and recognises training providers, recognises 28 of our auditor, HACCP, GMP and ISO courses, including four lead auditor courses, whether we deliver them in class, in live virtual classes or online.
News & updates 5 new
4.9/5 what do you need today?