To check the calibration of a probe thermometer, put it in a slurry of crushed ice and a little water, stir, wait for the reading to settle and accept it only if it reads between -1 °C and 1 °C. We recommend doing this at least weekly for every probe used at a critical control point, and recording the result. Once a year, send one reference thermometer to a laboratory accredited by SANAS for temperature, so that your checks trace back to a national standard. No South African regulation sets the frequency, but your scheme expects you to set one and justify it.
The check most kitchens and factories copy from overseas guidance adds a second test in boiling water, with a pass band of 99 °C to 101 °C. That band only works near sea level. In Johannesburg water boils at about 94 °C, so a perfectly good probe fails, and sites end up throwing away thermometers or, worse, quietly ignoring the test.
If your checks still live on a clipboard, ASCloud schedules them and flags the one that was missed.
In short
- The ice point check works everywhere in South Africa, but it proves the probe at 0 °C only. For a cooking CCP, also compare it with a reference near the critical limit.
- Boiling water does not reach 100 °C inland. Expect about 94 °C in Johannesburg and about 95.5 °C in Pretoria and Bloemfontein.
- Checking a probe is verification. Calibration means comparison against a reference with a certificate that traces to a national standard.
- When a probe fails, every reading since its last good check is in question, and so is the product those readings released.
- An auditor wants to see the probe’s ID, the date, the reading, the person and what was done when it failed.
Why the boiling water test fails on the Highveld
Water boils when its vapour pressure matches the air pressure above it. Air pressure falls as you climb, so water boils at a lower temperature. At sea level that is 100 °C. On the Highveld it is several degrees lower, and the difference is larger than the whole pass band most procedures allow.
We calculated the figures below from the International Standard Atmosphere pressure at each elevation and the vapour pressure curve of water. Daily weather moves them by a few tenths of a degree either way.
| Place | Elevation | Boils at about |
|---|---|---|
| Durban, Cape Town, Gqeberha | Near sea level | 100 °C |
| Pretoria | 1,340 m | 95.6 °C |
| Bloemfontein | 1,395 m | 95.4 °C |
| Johannesburg | 1,750 m | 94.2 °C |
So a Johannesburg butchery following a procedure written for London will see its probe read 94 °C in a rolling boil and conclude the probe is about 6 °C out. It is not. Our festive season hygiene audit article makes the same point for kitchens. If you already run a monthly two point check, set the boiling band from the table above rather than 99 °C to 101 °C. The boiling test can still be used inland if the pass band is set for your altitude, but the ice point check is simpler, needs no correction and sits closer to the chilled temperatures most probes spend their lives measuring.
For a cooking critical control point, a comparison against a reference thermometer near the cooking temperature is the better second check, and we explain it below.
The ice point check, step by step
The UK Food Standards Agency’s Safer Food, Better Business pack uses the same pass band for iced water that we recommend, -1 °C to 1 °C, and advises checking regularly, for example monthly, where the manufacturer gives no frequency. For probes that release product at a CCP, we would check weekly and after any drop, and busy plants often check daily at the start of the shift.
- Fill a clean container to the top with crushed ice, ideally made from potable water. Cubes leave warm pockets, so crush them.
- Add cold water until it just shows below the surface of the ice. You want a slurry, not ice floating in water.
- Stir and leave it for about two minutes so the whole mix settles at 0 °C.
- Push the probe into the centre to at least the depth the manufacturer specifies, without touching the sides or bottom.
- Wait until the reading stops changing, then read and record it with the probe’s ID, the date and your name.
- If it reads outside -1 °C to 1 °C, take it out of use, label it and follow your procedure for a failed device.
Many digital probes have no adjustment. A failed probe goes back to the supplier for calibration or is replaced. Do not apply a handwritten correction to a working probe on the line, because nobody remembers it at 02:00.
Verification on site, calibration in a laboratory
Auditors notice when the two words are used as if they meant the same thing.
Calibration compares an instrument against a reference of known accuracy and reports the error and the measurement uncertainty, on a certificate. For that certificate to carry weight, the laboratory should be accredited to ISO/IEC 17025 for the measurement, which in South Africa means accredited by SANAS. Those laboratories trace their results to the national measurement standards held by the National Metrology Institute of South Africa. Most sites keep one reference thermometer, have it calibrated by an accredited laboratory once a year, and use it to check the working probes.
Verification is that in-house check: the ice point test, or a side by side comparison of a working probe against the reference in a water bath held near the temperature that matters, such as 75 °C for a cooking step.
ISO 22000:2018 clause 8.7 asks for monitoring and measuring equipment to be calibrated or verified at specified intervals, with calibration traceable to international or national measurement standards, and it also asks for software used in monitoring and measuring to be validated before use. BRCGS Issue 9 covers the same ground in section 6.4 on the calibration and control of measuring and monitoring devices.
How a 0.8 °C probe error eats a 75 °C critical limit
Say a pie bakery in Midrand has a critical limit of 75 °C core temperature for its baked pies, monitored with a hand probe in the centre of the filling of a pie taken from the coolest position in the oven, found when the oven was mapped. The weekly check against the reference thermometer at 75 °C shows the working probe reads 0.8 °C high.
When that probe shows 75.0 °C, the pie is actually at about 74.2 °C. The bakery has been releasing product below its own critical limit while every record says it passed. A tolerance of plus or minus 1 °C on the probe is acceptable only if the operating target sits far enough above the critical limit to absorb it.
| Decision | What the bakery sets |
|---|---|
| Critical limit in the HACCP plan | 75 °C core |
| Maximum probe error allowed at the weekly check | Plus or minus 0.5 °C against the reference at 75 °C |
| Operating target for the oven exit check | 77 °C or higher before the batch moves on |
| Action if the weekly check fails | Probe out of use, every batch released since the last good check reviewed |
The 2 °C margin also has to cover the uncertainty printed on the reference thermometer’s certificate and the probe’s reading resolution, so add those before you settle on the operating target. In ASCloud the weekly probe check is scheduled against each probe’s ID, so the last good check is one search away.
The last row of that table is where most sites fall short. ISO 22000 clause 8.7 expects you to assess the validity of earlier results when equipment is found not to conform, and to act on any product affected. In practice that means pulling the records back to the last good check and deciding, batch by batch, what happens to anything still in your control. Fresh pies will mostly be eaten already, but a frozen range may still be in the cold chain. Our article on CCP deviations sets out how to document that decision.
The same logic applies to chilled holding. If your cold room limit is 5 °C and your probe reads 1 °C low, product you record at 4.5 °C was really at 5.5 °C. Our guide to cooking, cooling and hot holding CCPs shows where those limits come from.
Infrared guns, data loggers and fridge displays
An infrared thermometer reads only the surface it is pointed at. For packed food, that is the outside of the packaging, not the food. It is useful for a quick screen of a delivery but cannot tell you the core temperature of a chicken breast or a pot of stew. Never use it to release product at a cooking or cooling CCP.
Data loggers and the display on a cold room controller need checking too. Compare them with your verified probe in a glass of water left beside the sensor for at least an hour, at least monthly, and record it. A cold room display that reads 2 °C cold is a common reason for a chilled product complaint that nobody can explain.
The records an auditor will ask to see
Auditors pick a CCP record, note the probe used and then ask for its verification history. They want a list of every thermometer with a unique ID, a schedule, the reading and the person for each check, the action when one failed, and the current calibration certificate for the reference. Gaps in that chain are a frequent HACCP audit finding, and they are covered in our article on verification and validation.
This is where paper struggles. A check that is skipped on a busy Friday leaves no trace until the auditor finds the gap three months later. In ASCloud the probe calibration check sits in the scheduled checklist, the person doing it makes the record on a phone under their own name, and a check that is not done on time escalates to the supervisor. Our article on missed CCP checks explains why that alert matters.
Why food businesses choose ASC
Rated 4.9 out of 5 from more than 400 Google reviews across our three offices.
Gqeberha Google reviews Johannesburg Google reviews Cape Town Google reviews
Our online courses hold a 4.9 average from 2,647 course reviews and more than 7,200 course enrolments.
- ISO 9001 certified
- SAATCA registered online training course provider (TC 065)
- FoodBev SETA Accredited Provider No. 587/00337/1900
- Exemplar Global Recognised Training Provider
Stop chasing paper checks
ASCloud, the paperless food safety system built by ASC
Thermometer checks, CCP records and corrective actions on any phone, each record time stamped and signed by a named user, with missed checks escalated to the supervisor. Loaded with R638, HACCP to SANS 10330 or your GFSI scheme before your first login. R638 and Certificate of Acceptability plans from R499 per site per month, HACCP to SANS 10330 from R3,800 per site per month, excluding VAT, plus once-off setup from R3,850. Live in five working days, billed monthly with no long-term lock-in, and a 60-day money-back guarantee. Book a 20-minute demo and we load your scheme before the call.
See ASCloud and book a demo WhatsApp us for a demo
Training the person who signs the CCP records? HACCP for Supervisors and HACCP Teams (R2,450, HPCSA CPD accredited).
Questions we are often asked
How often should a probe thermometer be calibrated?
We recommend checking every working probe in iced water at least weekly if it is used at a CCP, and after any drop or knock. Probes used at a cooking or hot holding CCP should also be compared with the reference near the critical limit. Send one reference thermometer to a laboratory accredited by SANAS for temperature once a year.
What should a thermometer read in boiling water in Johannesburg?
About 94 °C, depending on the weather. Because the boiling point changes with altitude and air pressure, the ice point check at 0 °C is the more reliable test inland.
Can an infrared thermometer be used for cooking temperatures?
No. It measures only the surface. Use a calibrated probe in the thickest part of the food for any cooking, cooling or reheating CCP.
What do we do with product if a probe fails its check?
Take the probe out of use, find the last good check and review every batch released with that probe since then. Decide what happens to product still in your control, and record the decision and the reason.
Sources
- Food Standards Agency, Safer Food, Better Business, Management section, Prove it. GOV.UK
- ISO 22000:2018 with Amd 1:2024, Food safety management systems, clause 8.7 Control of monitoring and measuring. International Organization for Standardization.
- BRCGS Global Standard for Food Safety, Issue 9, section 6.4 Calibration and control of measuring and monitoring devices.
- ISO/IEC 17025:2017, General requirements for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories, and the South African National Accreditation System. sanas.co.za
- National Metrology Institute of South Africa. nmisa.org
- Boiling points calculated by ASC from the International Standard Atmosphere (ISO 2533:1975) pressure at each elevation and the Antoine equation for water.

