An internal food safety auditor is competent when you can show three things on paper: they were trained in auditing and in the standard they audit, they did not audit their own work, and their reports name the requirement, the evidence and the gap. BRCGS, IFS Food 8, FSSC 22000 and ISO 22000 all ask for this in different words, and a certification auditor will test it by reading your internal audit reports and then talking to the person who wrote them.
It matters more than most sites think. Internal audit is a fundamental requirement in BRCGS Food Safety Issue 9 and a KO requirement in IFS Food 8, so a weak programme can cost the certificate rather than earn a minor. In South Africa the problem is usually size: a factory with two people in QA has to audit the QA department too, and nobody wants to audit the HACCP plan they wrote.
The hardest part on a small site is independence, so most of this post is about that, and about writing findings that survive a certification audit. If your auditors have never had formal training our Internal and Supplier Auditing Practices course is built for exactly this job.
In short
- BRCGS Issue 9 clause 3.4 is a fundamental requirement. Clause 3.4.2 asks for trained, competent auditors who do not audit their own work.
- IFS Food 8 makes the internal audit programme KO number 8 (clause 5.1.1), and clause 5.1.2 requires auditors who are competent and independent of the department audited.
- ISO 22000 clause 9.2.2 asks for competent auditors chosen so that the audit is objective and impartial, with results reported to the food safety team and relevant management.
- No scheme requires a single site’s internal auditor to be externally registered, but SAATCA does offer an Internal Auditor grade for people who want it.
- ISO 19011, the guidance on auditing, now has a 2026 edition that replaces the 2018 one.
What the standards ask for internal auditor competence
The wording differs, but the core is the same in every scheme: training and independence, with reporting that rests on evidence. The table sets the clauses side by side so you can check your own procedure against them.
| Standard | Who may audit | How often |
|---|---|---|
| BRCGS Food Safety Issue 9 | Clause 3.4.2: appropriately trained, competent auditors, independent of the area audited, so they do not audit their own work | Clause 3.4.1: at least four audit dates spread through the year, every activity covered at least once a year, frequency set by risk |
| IFS Food Version 8 | Clause 5.1.2: competent and independent from the audited department | Clause 5.1.1: planned within 12 months, carried out within 15 months at most, critical activities audited more often |
| ISO 22000:2018 (the base of FSSC 22000) | Clause 9.2.2 c): competent auditors, selected so that the audit is objective and impartial | Clause 9.2.2 a): planned intervals based on process importance, changes in the system and previous results |
| FSSC 22000 Version 7, multi-site | Part 2, 2.5.18.2: auditors independent of the areas they audit, with minimum training and experience (see below) | Every site and the central function at least once a year, more often where risk demands |
What is at stake differs. BRCGS clause 3.4 is a fundamental requirement, so a major or critical non-conformity against it means no certificate. IFS clause 5.1.1 is KO number 8, and a D score on a KO stops certification. Under ISO 22000 your certification body grades the nonconformity, and for FSSC 22000 multi-site organisations it checks internal auditor competence every year. FSSC 22000 Version 7 also asks for the quality elements of the scheme to be included in the internal audit scope (Part 2, 2.5.9). Version 6 is audited until 30 April 2027 and Version 7 audits start on 1 May 2027.
BRCGS also asks, in clause 3.4.4, for a separate programme of documented hygiene and fabrication inspections at least once a month in open product areas. Those inspections are not internal audits, and an auditor who walks the floor once a month does not cover clause 3.4.1. Our guide to a risk based internal audit schedule shows how to plan both.
IFS puts its site inspections in clause 5.2.1, with frequency based on risk and past results. The detail of the IFS KO requirements, including the internal audit KO, is in our post on IFS Food 8 KO requirements and the unannounced audit.
How much training does an internal auditor need?
For a single site, no scheme sets a number of hours. The schemes ask you to define the competence yourself and prove it, which ISO 22000 clause 7.2 describes as competence on the basis of appropriate education, training or experience, with documented evidence kept.
In practice an auditor will look for a certificate from an internal auditor course, training in the standard being audited, and some record that the person has actually done audits under supervision before auditing alone.
The only scheme that writes the numbers down is FSSC 22000, and only for multi-site certification in categories BIII, E, F and G. Version 7 Part 2 clause 2.5.18.2 asks for two years of full-time food industry experience, at least one of them in the organisation, and a higher education course or five years of relevant work experience. The internal lead auditor needs a 40 hour lead auditor course in FSMS, QMS or FSSC 22000. Other internal auditors need a 16 hour internal auditor course on audit principles, practices and techniques, and every auditor needs at least 8 hours of training in the FSSC scheme.
Those numbers make a fair benchmark for every site, including single sites. An auditor’s file that meets the FSSC multi-site test will stand up well at a single-site BRCGS or IFS audit. Our Internal and Supplier Auditing Practices course runs to about 24 hours, above the FSSC 16 hour minimum, and ends with a case study audit your auditor completes and can put in their file.
Training in the standard matters as much as training in auditing. An auditor who has never read the FSSC additional requirements cannot audit them, and ISO 22000 clause 9.2.1 asks internal audits to confirm conformity with the standard as well as with your own system. The BRCGS Issue 9 training matrix post shows how to record this for every role, auditors included.
Independence on a small site
Independence is where small South African sites get caught. BRCGS is blunt: auditors shall be independent, that is, they shall not audit their own work. IFS says independent from the audited department. If the technical manager wrote the HACCP plan and the same person audits the HACCP plan, the audit fails that test, however good the report reads.
The fix is a rotation, written into the audit programme so the auditor can see it was planned. Take a juice and dairy blend plant in Gqeberha with 85 staff, a technical manager, one QA technologist and BRCGS certification. It trained four people as internal auditors: the QA technologist, the production supervisor, the stores controller and the engineering foreman. The programme then looks like this.
| When and what | Who audits, and why |
|---|---|
| February: goods receiving, raw material storage and supplier approval | Production supervisor. Does not work in stores or purchasing |
| May: production, CCPs and allergen changeover | Stores controller with the QA technologist. Neither runs the line, and the QA technologist supplies the HACCP knowledge |
| August: engineering, maintenance and calibration | QA technologist. Independent of engineering |
| November: HACCP plan, document control, internal audit and management review | External auditor. The technical manager and QA wrote these documents, so nobody on site can audit them independently |
Cleaning, pest control, food defence, food fraud and the other prerequisite programmes are split across the same four dates, so the programme covers every activity, not only the ones in the table.
That gives four audit dates spread through the year, which BRCGS clause 3.4.1 asks for, and every activity covered at least once a year. The one area nobody inside can audit independently goes to an outside auditor once a year. That is the cheapest honest answer for most sites with a small technical team, and it is the gap our internal food safety audit service is usually asked to fill.
What a finding that holds up looks like
Certification auditors read internal audit reports to judge the auditor. A report full of ticks with a handful of “not done” comments tells them the audit was a walk through, not an audit. BRCGS clause 3.4.3 asks reports to record conformity as well as non-conformity, with objective evidence, and IFS clause 5.1.3 asks for compliances, deviations and non-conformities to be documented and communicated.
A useful test is whether a stranger could read the finding cold and go and see the problem. Compare these two findings from the May audit at the Gqeberha plant.
Weak: “Metal detector checks not always done. Operators to be reminded.”
Strong: “Procedure QP 12 requires the metal detector on line 2 to be checked with the 2.0 mm ferrous, 2.5 mm non-ferrous and 3.0 mm stainless test pieces at start-up and every two hours. The check sheet for 14 May shows start-up and 10:00 checks, then no entries until 16:00. Production ran 2,400 bottles between those checks, none of them covered by a verified detector check. Non-conformity. Raised with the shift supervisor. Agreed action and date to be recorded on the corrective action register.”
The second version names the requirement, gives the evidence, states the gap and its consequence, and leaves the fix to the people who own the line. It is also the kind of finding that feeds a proper root cause analysis rather than a reminder that changes nothing.
Verification closes the loop. Every scheme asks for actions to be followed up and checked, and ISO 22000 clause 9.2.2 asks for correction and corrective action within the agreed time frame. An auditor who raises findings and never goes back to check them is doing half the job.
Does an internal auditor need SAATCA registration?
No. None of the schemes requires a single site’s internal auditor to be registered with SAATCA or any other body. SAATCA does run an Internal Auditor grade for people who audit inside the organisation that employs them. It asks for the same qualifications and experience as its Auditor grade. The certification is tied to that employer and falls away when the person leaves, and SAATCA states the grade is not IPC recognised or SANAS accredited. Some sites use it to show a customer that their auditors meet a recognised benchmark. It is a choice, not a requirement.
What every scheme does require is a training record you can hand over. ISO 19011, the international guidance on auditing management systems, sets out in its clause 7 how to define auditor competence and how to keep it up. Its 2026 edition replaced the 2018 one in May 2026, so a procedure that still cites ISO 19011:2018 should be updated at its next review.
A short checklist for your internal auditor files
Before your next certification audit, open the file for each internal auditor and check that it holds the items below. If one is missing, that is the question the auditor will ask.
- A certificate from an internal auditor course that covered audit principles from planning through to reporting and follow-up.
- Training in the standard being audited, at the edition you are certified to.
- A record of at least one audit done under supervision before auditing alone.
- An annual review of the auditor’s reports by the technical manager or an outside auditor.
- The audit programme showing who audited what, so independence can be seen at a glance.
If those files are thin, the cheapest fix is formal training now, on our Internal and Supplier Auditing Practices course, before the December shutdown, so the first audit dates of 2027 are done by people who can defend their findings. For the supplier side of the job, see our post on building internal and supplier auditors.
Why food businesses choose ASC
Rated 4.9 out of 5 from more than 400 Google reviews across our three offices.
Gqeberha Google reviews Johannesburg Google reviews Cape Town Google reviews
Our online courses hold a 4.9 average from more than 2,600 course reviews and more than 7,200 course enrolments.
ISO 9001 certified. SAATCA registered online training course provider (TC 065). FoodBev SETA Accredited Provider No. 587/00337/1900. Exemplar Global Recognised Training Provider.
Train your internal auditors
Internal and Supplier Auditing Practices based on FSMS
Online and self paced, about 24 hours of learning, or 2.5 days in a live virtual class. It covers the internal audit requirements of ISO 22000 and FSSC 22000, BRCGS, IFS and GLOBALG.A.P., the principles of auditing, and worked examples of the programme, the plan, the opening and closing meetings and corrective action, ending with a case study audit you complete yourself. Recognised by Exemplar Global under its Recognised Training Provider scheme. Learners should already know the food safety standard they will audit. R3,650 per learner, with lifetime access, which is small against a weak internal audit programme, a BRCGS fundamental and an IFS KO. Training four auditors? WhatsApp us for a team quote and invoice.
See the course and enrol WhatsApp us about team training
Need an independent auditor for the areas you cannot audit yourselves? Internal food safety audits by ASC (free, no obligation quote, charged hourly).
Questions we are often asked
Can a QA manager audit their own department?
Not under BRCGS or IFS. BRCGS clause 3.4.2 says auditors shall not audit their own work, and IFS clause 5.1.2 asks for auditors independent from the audited department. Use another trained auditor from the site, or an external auditor, for the QA and HACCP systems.
How many internal audits does BRCGS Issue 9 require?
Clause 3.4.1 asks for a scheduled programme with at least four different audit dates spread through the year, with every activity audited at least once a year and higher risk activities more often.
Is internal audit a KO requirement in IFS Food 8?
Yes. Clause 5.1.1, the internal audit programme, is KO number 8. It must be planned within 12 months and carried out within 15 months at most, and cover all IFS requirements.
How long is an internal auditor course?
There is no fixed legal length for a single site. FSSC 22000 Version 7 sets a 16 hour minimum for internal auditors in multi-site organisations in some categories, which is a sensible benchmark. Our online internal auditor course runs to about 24 hours.
Sources
- BRCGS, Global Standard for Food Safety Issue 9, clauses 3.4.1 to 3.4.4
- IFS, IFS Food Version 8, Standard for assessing product and process compliance, clauses 5.1.1 to 5.1.3 and 5.2.1
- FSSC, FSSC 22000 Scheme Version 7, Part 2, clauses 2.5.9 and 2.5.18.2
- ISO, ISO 22000:2018 Food safety management systems, clauses 7.2 and 9.2
- ISO 19011:2026, Guidelines for auditing management systems, fourth edition, May 2026, clause 7
- SAATCA, Auditor grades

