New: ASCloud, our paperless food safety system. Full document FSMS from R3,800 a month, R638 plans from R499. See pricing

Food fraud vulnerability assessment: a worked example

A food fraud vulnerability assessment looks at every material you buy, pack or sell and asks one question: how easy and how tempting would it be for someone in the supply chain to cheat on it for money? You score each material group against a fixed set of factors, decide which vulnerabilities are significant, and put controls on those. The result has to be written down, owned by a competent team and reviewed whenever the supply chain changes.

Every GFSI recognised scheme asks for it, FSSC 22000 and BRCGS included, and auditors in South Africa raise it often. The usual problem is a spreadsheet where every line scores “low”, nothing links to a control, and nobody on site can explain why beef trimmings from a new trader carry the same rating as printed film.

Below we score a sausage and polony plant in Gauteng, factor by factor. Our guide to scoring a VACCP assessment covers the method in full, and our Food Fraud Tool gives you eleven pre-written material groups to edit for your site.

In short

  • Food fraud is cheating for economic gain. It is assessed separately from food defence, which deals with people who want to cause harm.
  • FSSC 22000 Version 7 points to ISO 22002-100:2025 clause 16.3 for the assessment and adds its own requirement 2.5.4, which asks that competent people develop and maintain it.
  • Score each material group on factors such as price pressure, fraud history and detectability. Price and history are usually outside your control.
  • Every significant vulnerability needs a named control and an owner, plus proof that the control is checked.
  • Review the assessment at least once a year and every time the supply chain changes.

What the schemes ask for in 2026

In GFSI’s definition, food fraud is deliberate cheating for economic gain. It reaches beyond the food itself to its packaging and labels, and to any claim made about the product. Every recognised scheme carries that expectation, though the wording and the clause numbers differ.

In FSSC 22000 Version 7, published in May 2026, the core requirement sits in ISO 22002-100:2025, clause 16.3, and FSSC adds three points of its own.

Under 2.5.4 (a), the assessment and the mitigation plan must be developed and maintained by people with the right knowledge and competence. Under 2.5.4 (b), the plan must be implemented, supported by the FSMS, legally compliant, cover everything in scope and be kept up to date. Category FII sites must also make sure their suppliers have a plan. Our post on ISO 22002-100:2025 maps the new clause numbers.

Version 6 audits run until 30 April 2027, and upgrade audits to Version 7 take place between 1 May 2027 and 30 April 2028. Our FSSC 22000 Version 7 deadline guide shows how to find your own upgrade date.

BRCGS Food Safety Issue 9 covers it in section 5.4. Raw materials are assessed for adulteration and substitution, considering fraud history and the economic pressures that make cheating attractive, and the assessment is formally reviewed every year.

IFS Food Version 8 covers it in section 4.20, food fraud, with a review at least every 12 months or after significant changes. Our post on the IFS Food 8 KO requirements explains how IFS grades what it finds.

Food fraud and food defence are two different assessments

Food defence also deals with deliberate acts, but the motive differs. A fraudster wants money and needs the product to stay saleable. A food defence threat wants to cause harm. Keep two assessments, even in one file. Our guide to the food defence threat assessment covers the second.

Why a South African site cannot treat this as paperwork

In 2013, researchers at Stellenbosch University tested 139 processed meat products bought from South African retailers and butcheries. They found species not declared on the label in 68 per cent of them, most often in sausages, burger patties and deli meats. Pork and chicken were the usual substitutes. Donkey and water buffalo also turned up, along with goat.

Soya and gluten that were not declared turned up in more than 28 per cent of samples, which is also an allergen failure (Cawthorn and colleagues, Food Control, 2013).

Spices tell the same story. An EU control plan on herbs and spices tested 1,885 samples and found 17 per cent suspicious of adulteration. The rate was 48 per cent for oregano, 17 per cent for pepper, 14 per cent for cumin and 6 per cent for paprika and chilli (European Commission Joint Research Centre, 2021).

The meat study is 13 years old and no national survey has followed, so horizon scanning has to feed your scores.

A product that contains something it does not declare is misdescribed. Section 41 of the Consumer Protection Act prohibits misleading representations about goods, and R146 requires the ingredient list to declare what the product contains. An undeclared allergen such as soya can also mean a recall, which our labelling and regulatory team helps sites manage.

How to score a food fraud vulnerability assessment

No single method is prescribed. Our Food Fraud Tool scores each material group from 1 (low) to 3 (high) on seven factors. Price and history describe the market and rarely change. The other five describe your supply chain and controls, which is where mitigation works.

FactorScores 1 whenScores 3 when
Economic vulnerabilityStable price, no cheap look-alikeCheaper substitute or short supply
Historical dataNo known fraud in this materialDocumented fraud here or abroad
DetectabilityRoutine checks would catch itOnly DNA or isotope tests would
Supply chain accessSealed from origin to your doorRepacked or blended on the way
Supplier relationshipLong-standing and directA new supplier or spot buying
Certification and assuranceGFSI certified with fraud controlsNo independent assurance
Chain complexityStraight from the producerTraders and several origins

Group materials sensibly: imported and locally milled paprika have different chains, so they are separate groups. Packaging, supplier documents and your own finished product belong on the list too, because a forged certificate is fraud.

A worked example: a sausage and polony plant in Gauteng

Take an FSSC 22000 certified plant making beef boerewors and polony. It buys beef trimmings from two abattoirs and, since a winter price spike, from a meat trader. Spices come from a local blender and printed film from a certified converter. The team, buyer included, scored three groups.

Factor (1 to 3)Beef trimPaprikaFilm
Economic vulnerability321
Historical data331
Detectability321
Supply chain access221
Supplier relationship211
Certification and assurance211
Chain complexity331
Total out of 2118147

Beef trimmings score high on price and history for obvious reasons: pork and chicken cost less than beef, and the 2013 study found exactly that substitution in South African sausages. Detectability is a 3 because nobody on the receiving bay can tell beef from pork in frozen trimmings. Only a species PCR test, which is a DNA method, can.

Paprika scores 3 on history because the spice survey above found adulteration in paprika and chilli. The plant’s full list also covers mechanically recovered meat, binders and premixes, where hidden soya and gluten usually come from, and casings.

The new trader pushes the relationship and complexity scores up, because he buys from several abattoirs and the plant could not say which one supplied a given carton.

This team set its own decision rule before scoring: any group totalling 15 or more is significant and needs a dedicated mitigation measure. Beef trimmings are significant. Paprika, at 14, stays under routine supplier controls and gets a closer look at the next review.

Turning the score into a mitigation plan

For the beef trimmings the plant agreed five measures. The specification is reissued to state beef only, the abattoir of origin, no mechanically recovered meat or offal, and the delivery temperature. The trader must name the abattoir on every delivery note, and the plant accepts only abattoirs on its approved list. A quantitative species PCR test is run on trimmings from each supplier every quarter and on the first three deliveries from any new supplier, at a laboratory accredited for the method.

The trader supplies abattoir invoices that cover the volumes sold to the plant, so he cannot sell more abattoir beef than he bought. And the trader receives a second party audit before the end of the year.

PCR picks up traces carried over on shared equipment, so the plan sets an action level with the laboratory, often about 1 per cent. A pork result above it in a beef lot triggers quarantine, a recall assessment and suspension of the supplier until the cause is found.

Then the team re-scored with the measures in place. Detectability falls from 3 to 1 because testing now exists, assurance falls to 1 because of the audit, and complexity falls to 2 because every carton can now be traced to an abattoir. The residual total is 14, below the line.

Price and history stay at 3, which is honest. The controls make cheating easier to catch, but beef costs what it costs. Residual scores only count once each control is in place and verified, and because the lower score depends on them, the measures stay in the plan.

To score your own groups this way, the ASC Food Fraud Tool has the seven factors and the mitigation plan built in. If you would rather we do the first assessment with you, send us a WhatsApp for a free, no obligation quote. Consulting is charged hourly.

What auditors find wrong

The most common finding is an assessment that stops at raw materials, leaving out packaging, supplier certificates and claims such as halaal, all easy to forge. Next comes scoring without evidence: if paprika scores 1 for history, the file should show where the team looked and when.

Auditors also flag assessments that never change after a supplier switch, and plans naming controls nobody carries out. Under FSSC 22000 Version 7, expect questions on the competence of whoever did the work. Our Food Fraud Coordinator Course is built for that person.

Food fraud is one of the risk assessments in our guide to the 24 risk assessments a GFSI audit expects, which shows how it links to supplier approval and traceability.

Why food businesses choose ASC

Rated 4.9 out of 5 from more than 400 Google reviews across our three offices.

Gqeberha Google reviews Johannesburg Google reviews Cape Town Google reviews

Our online courses hold a 4.9 average from 2,660 course reviews and more than 7,200 course enrolments.

ASC is ISO 9001 certified, a SAATCA registered online training course provider (TC 065), FoodBev SETA Accredited Provider No. 587/00337/1900 and an Exemplar Global Recognised Training Provider.

Score your food fraud risks this week

ASC Food Fraud Tool, 12 month site licence

Eleven pre-written, pre-scored material groups, from bulk liquids and spices to packaging and returns, each with a fraud scenario you edit. Seven factor scoring, a mitigation plan, risk register and action tracker, exported to Excel. It runs in the browser and maps to ISO 22002-100, FSSC 22000 Version 7, BRCGS Issue 9 and SQF Edition 9. Your team still scores your own risks and runs the controls. R750 per site per year, about R62 a month.

Get the Food Fraud Tool Ask us on WhatsApp

FSSC 22000 Version 7 asks for a competent lead. Train yours on the Food Fraud Coordinator Course (R1,750).

Questions we are often asked

How often should a food fraud vulnerability assessment be reviewed?

BRCGS Issue 9 asks for a review at least once a year, and every scheme expects one whenever something material changes, such as a new supplier, a price spike or an industry fraud incident. Record the date and what was considered, even when the scores stay the same.

Does a small food business need one?

R638 does not require one. You need one if you are certified to a GFSI scheme or supply a retailer that asks for it. Smaller sites have fewer groups, so the work is shorter.

Do we have to test every material?

No. Testing is one control among several, and it belongs where detectability is the weak point. Supplier approval and direct buying do most of the work for most materials, backed by specifications and quantity checks such as invoice reconciliation. Use the scores to decide where testing earns its cost.

Leave a Comment

I accept the Terms and Conditions and the Privacy Policy

Exemplar Global Recognised Training Provider (RTP) badge issued to ASC Food Safety
International recognitionExemplar Global Recognised Training Provider (RTP)Exemplar Global, the international organisation that certifies auditors and recognises training providers, recognises 28 of our auditor, HACCP, GMP and ISO courses, including four lead auditor courses, whether we deliver them in class, in live virtual classes or online.
News & updates 5 new
4.9/5 what do you need today?